Fears of an AI bubble bursting are gaining traction, but ETF investors appear to be sending a more complicated signal.
While concerns about NVIDIA Corp’s (NASDAQ:NVDA) leadership turmoil and the sustainability of massive AI capital expenditure have weighed on sentiment, billions of dollars continue to flow into technology-focused ETFs.
• VanEck Semiconductor ETF shares are consolidating. What’s the outlook for SMH shares?
The Kobeissi Letter, in a post on X, highlighted the cautious sentiment of AI investors: “Because of a personal event involving Jensen Huang, there are now widespread calls that the ‘AI bubble has popped.’”
“Sentiment is as though AI has failed, the investment wave is over, and we are in a global depression,” it said. The post continues after that.
The latest fund-flow data suggest investors are not abandoning the AI trade entirely. Instead, they appear to be selectively adding exposure to semiconductor stocks and disruptive technology while becoming more cautious about software and other speculative growth segments.
According to ETFThemes data as of Wednesday, four ETFs — the VanEck Semiconductor ETF (NASDAQ:SMH), iShares Semiconductor ETF (NASDAQ:SOXX), ARK Innovation ETF (BATS:ARKK) and ARK Next Generation Internet ETF (BATS:ARKW) — attracted approximately $14 billion in combined one-month inflows, despite losing between 12.8% and 14.8% over the same period.
The semiconductor trade remains particularly interesting. SMH attracted $5.11 billion over one month, while SOXX collected another $2.79 billion, even as both ETFs declined approximately 14% or more. However, the latest weekly figures reveal some hesitation. SOXX recorded $4.68 billion in outflows, while SMH attracted just $108 million, suggesting that dip-buying conviction may be weakening.
Investors Are Becoming More Selective About AI
The divergence becomes clearer when software ETFs enter the picture. The iShares Expanded Tech-Software Sector ETF (BATS:IGV) experienced $1.48 billion in one-month outflows, suggesting investors are less willing to maintain exposure to the broader technology growth trade.
Meanwhile, the First Trust Nasdaq Artificial Intelligence and Robotics ETF (NYSE:BAI) attracted $663 million, indicating continued interest in dedicated AI exposure. However, the broader thematic ETF universe recorded approximately $6.7 billion in net redemptions outside the four leading inflow recipients.
This selective positioning comes against a backdrop of growing institutional caution. Bank of America’s November fund manager survey, cited by Reuters, found that investors’ net overweight allocation to technology stocks fell to 12% from 37% a month earlier. A record 38% of respondents also believed companies were overinvesting, while 52% expected an AI hyperscaler to announce capital expenditure cuts within six months. Reuters
The Next AI Trade May Look Different
The numbers suggest that investors are distinguishing between companies directly exposed to AI infrastructure spending and businesses whose valuations depend on broader expectations of AI adoption.
For ETF investors, the distinction matters. Semiconductor ETFs continue to attract substantial monthly capital despite steep losses, but recent weekly withdrawals show that conviction is not uniform.
Rather than interpreting every AI-related sell-off as an opportunity, investors should watch whether semiconductor inflows stabilize, whether software redemptions persist and whether capital broadens into other AI beneficiaries.
The AI trade may not be over, but the days when investors bought almost anything carrying an AI label could be numbered.
Photo: Shutterstock
