Shares of CarMax Inc (NYSE:KMX) rose in early trading on Thursday after the company reported upbeat first-quarter results.
Driven by market share gains and internal efficiency improvements, the company achieved higher-than-expected retail gross profit per unit in the quarter, improving its earnings profile, according to Needham.
The CarMax Analyst: Needham analyst Chris Pierce reiterated a Hold rating on the stock.
The CarMax Thesis: The company indicated that unit growth was driven by pricing, while citing this as a one-time lever “with no longer-term plans to sacrifice margins for growth,” Pierce said in the note.
Check out other analyst stock ratings.
CarMax’s kickstart in unit growth in the first quarter supports an improved GPU outlook, with improved efficiencies expected to drive competitive pricing starting in fiscal 2028, the analyst stated.
“Against relatively easy retail unit comparisons through the remainder of FY27, the setup for positive comps appears favorable if current pricing, marketing and conversion initiatives continue to gain traction,” he further wrote.
Pierce expressed concerns around:
- Reported retail comps in the negative territory: The company has yet to demonstrate sustained retail unit growth.
- Risk remaining elevated: Carvana Co (NYSE:CVNA) is still the “largest strategic overhang.” If this company begins passing its efficiency gains and industry-leading margins to consumers in the form of lower ASPs (average selling prices), CarMax may be forced to offer pricing concessions to maintain volumes.
- Q1 boosted by one-time benefits: The latest results included a reserve benefit of around $25 million in CAF (Carmax Auto Finance) linked to previously provisioned loans.
The analyst further wrote, “The core debate remains unresolved: can KMX show evidence of durable, profitable unit growth?”
KMX Price Action: Shares of CarMax had risen by 4.03% to $49.34 at the time of publication on Thursday.
Image: Shutterstock
